# Side channel or rotary lobe blower: which for which pressure?

**Side channel blower or rotary lobe blower: which one for which pressure?**

The US EPA's 2010 report on energy conservation in wastewater treatment says rotary lobe (positive displacement) machines deliver a fixed volume of air per shaft revolution over a wide range of discharge pressures, 1 to 14 psig in its table; Elmo Rietschle says side channel blowers excel at high flow rates and moderate vacuum.

| Aspect | Side channel (regenerative) | Rotary lobe |
|---|---|---|
| How it compresses | The impeller, mounted on the motor shaft, accelerates the gas in the side channel by centrifugal force: contact-free flow compression (Elmo Rietschle) | Positive displacement: two counter-rotating shafts with 2- or 3-lobed impellers give a fixed volume of air for every shaft revolution (EPA 2010) |
| Stages and internal compression | Two- and three-stage models compress the gas across several stages for higher pressure ratios (Elmo Rietschle) | Elmo Rietschle describes the traditional rotary lobe design as being without internal compression |
| Pressure the sources give | Pressures or vacuums lower than typical compressors and higher than centrifugal fans, in some cases over 10 psig (US 11,815,105, background); Elmo Rietschle gives the differential pressure per model | 1 to 14 psig at 5 to 50,000 scfm for aeration blowers (EPA 2010, from WEF 2009 and WEF and ASCE 2010) |
| Oil | Dry-running (Elmo Rietschle) | Compression chamber free of grease or oil; gearbox and bearings oil-lubricated (Elmo Rietschle R-VWP) |
| Flow control | Frequency converters adapt speed and performance to changing load (Elmo Rietschle) | Simple control for constant flow; difficult to operate at variable flow rates without a VFD (EPA 2010) |
| Service and noise | Up to 20,000 hours between services (Elmo Rietschle G-Series) | Can be noisy, with enclosures commonly used; require more maintenance than the other aeration blower types in the table (EPA 2010) |
| Uses in the sources | Pneumatic conveying, drying and process air, vacuum lifting and handling, aeration and ventilation of water tanks and processes, packaging support (Elmo Rietschle); vacuum lifting and vacuum packaging (US 11,815,105) | Wastewater aeration (EPA 2010); boosters on a vane or screw backing pump in vacuum pump sets (Elmo Rietschle) |

## Which one for which pressure

The sources do not put both machines on one scale: the EPA table, written for wastewater aeration, gives psig, while Elmo Rietschle gives side channel pressures per model on its datasheets. The background of US patent 11,815,105 places side channel (regenerative) blowers between centrifugal fans and typical compressors, and calls them comparatively simple, medium speed machines, unlike positive displacement compressors with their complex assembly and high parts count. Elmo Rietschle says side channel blowers are particularly suitable when a continuous, low-pulsation airflow is required and the vacuum lies in the low to medium range, and that clean, dry gases are preferred.

For positive displacement blowers, the EPA table, which compares them with centrifugal machines, lists the ability to achieve higher output pressure at the same air flow rates among their advantages, and noise, more maintenance and difficult operation at variable flow without a VFD among their disadvantages.

## In aeration

The EPA report describes aeration blowers as essentially low pressure, high volume air compressors. Elmo Rietschle lists aeration and ventilation, for example of water tanks and process aeration, among side channel blower applications, and the patent background lists sewage aeration and aquaculture or pond aeration among regenerative blower uses. See [oil-free blowers for wastewater aeration](https://library.ultracontrolo.com/industry/blowers-for-wastewater-aeration/) and [what maintenance aeration blowers need](https://library.ultracontrolo.com/answers/what-maintenance-does-a-wastewater-blower-need/).

Ultra Controlo distributes and services Elmo Rietschle vacuum pumps and blowers in Portugal as a partner brand, and its UltraCare programme covers preventive and corrective maintenance, original spare parts and emergency support for partner-brand equipment.

### Is a side channel blower the same as a regenerative blower?

Yes: Elmo Rietschle says side channel blowers are also referred to as regenerative blowers, and the background of US patent 11,815,105 (2023) uses both names.

### Is there oil in a rotary lobe machine?

In Elmo Rietschle's R-VWP rotary lobe pumps the compression chamber is free of grease or oil, while the gearbox and bearings are oil-lubricated.

## Sources

- [US EPA, Evaluation of Energy Conservation Measures for Wastewater Treatment Facilities (September 2010)](https://19january2021snapshot.epa.gov/sites/static/files/2016-01/documents/p1008sbm.pdf)
- [US Patent 11,815,105 B2, Regenerative blowers-compressors with shaft bypass fluid re-vents (granted 14 November 2023), background](https://patents.google.com/patent/US11815105B2/en)
- [Elmo Rietschle, Side Channel Blowers](https://www.elmorietschle.com/en/side-channel/)
- [Elmo Rietschle, Dry Claw Vacuum Pumps](https://www.elmorietschle.com/en/claw-vacuum-pumps/)
- [Elmo Rietschle, Rotary Lobe Vacuum Pump R-VWP](https://www.elmorietschle.com/en/rotary-lobe-vacuum-pump/)
- [Elmo Rietschle, Product Guide ER.BP.PG.EN.26.03 (PDF), p. 8](https://azure-na-assets.contentstack.com/v3/assets/blt948736820c6caddf/blt59943408fb8903b9/6a79c297c141c4b40629c129/12426_IR_ER_Product_Guide_ENG_26_3.pdf)
- Ultra Controlo, Industrial 2026 catalogue, pp. 10 and 22

Reviewed: 2026-11-19. Ultra Controlo engineering. https://library.ultracontrolo.com/compare/side-channel-vs-rotary-lobe-blower/
