Medical gas library

Industry

Oil-free vs oil-injected compressors for industry

Short answer

The US Department of Energy compressed air sourcebook (third edition, 2016) says lubricant-free air can come from lubricant-free compressors or from lubricant-injected compressors with added separation and filtration, so the choice rests on the end use and on the risk and cost of product contamination.

What the DOE sourcebook says decides it

The sourcebook (page 20) names whether or not lubricant-free air is required as one of the main factors in determining air quality. It says lubricant-free rotary screw and reciprocating compressors usually have higher first costs, lower efficiency and higher maintenance costs than lubricant-injected compressors. It adds that the separation and filtration equipment a lubricant-injected compressor needs will cause some reduction in efficiency, particularly if the system is not properly maintained.

Before choosing, the sourcebook says, careful consideration should be given to the specific end use for the lubricant-free air, including the risk and cost associated with product contamination.

PointLubricant-free compressorLubricant-injected compressor
Rotary screw compression chamber (DOE, page 8)No lubricant introduced into the compression chamberLubricant injected into the compression chamber
How lubricant-free air is obtained (DOE, page 20)From the compressor itselfWith additional separation and filtration equipment
First cost, efficiency and maintenance cost, rotary screw and reciprocating (DOE, page 20)Usually higher first cost, lower efficiency, higher maintenance costUsually lower first cost, higher efficiency, lower maintenance cost, with some efficiency loss from the added separation and filtration
Discharge pressure listed for rotary screw (DOE, page 8)Dry type: single-stage units up to 50 psig, two-stage generally up to 150 psigSingle-stage packages from 50 to 250 psig; some two-stage versions up to 500 psig

What oil-free describes, and what a purity class describes

In the sourcebook (page 8), lubricant-free rotary screw compression works without lubricant being introduced into the compression chamber, and these compressors still use lubricant for bearings and gears that are isolated from the compression chamber. The words describe the compression chamber, not every part of the machine.

ISO 8573-1:2010 describes the air instead. According to the AFNOR and SIS catalogue entries, it specifies purity classes of compressed air with respect to particles, water and oil, independent of the location in the system at which the air is specified or measured. A purity class is therefore a property of the air at a point, not of the compressor type. See ISO 8573-1 and Class 0.

Ultra Controlo lines on each side

  • ULTRACECO SCA: the datasheet states compression exempt of oil or grease, without gearbox and belt driven.
  • ULTRACECO SCR: the datasheet describes a patented oil mist remover that recaptures gearcase oil mists and, in its words, helps ensure oil free air compression.
  • ULTRASCREW: the datasheet describes an oil injected rotary screw compressor.
  • ULTRAK activated carbon towers: the datasheet says they separate oil vapours from compressed air and that a coalescing filter is required upstream; it gives a nominal residual oil vapour content below 0.003 mg/m³.

The ULTRACECO SCA and SCR datasheets do not state an ISO 8573-1 class for the compressor. They say the unit can be completed with an air receiver, dryers and filters and that the air quality will match the application requirements.

More questions

Does oil-free compression mean the air is ISO 8573-1 class 0?

Not by itself. ISO 8573-1 classes describe the air at the point where it is specified or measured, and the ULTRACECO SCA and SCR datasheets state oil-free compression, not a class.

Are lubricant-free compressors less efficient?

The DOE sourcebook (2016) says lubricant-free rotary screw and reciprocating compressors are generally less efficient than lubricant-injected machines, and that the separation and filtration added to a lubricant-injected compressor also reduces efficiency somewhat.

Sources

Ultra Controlo figures come from its technical datasheets. Third-party facts were read at the source on the date shown.

Reviewed: · Ultra Controlo engineering · Markdown version

Related