Medical gas library

Oxygen and PSA

Galvanic vs ultrasonic handheld oxygen analysers

Short answer

In WHO-UNICEF's 2019 comparison of handheld oxygen analysers, a galvanic cell analyser works for concentrator oxygen and the low-pressure side of a cylinder supply but needs calibration and replacement sensors, while an ultrasonic analyser needs neither but is for PSA-generated oxygen below 96%.

WHO-UNICEF (2019, chapter 8) names three common oxygen sensor technologies: electrochemical (involving galvanic cells), ultrasonic and paramagnetic. It compares the first two in its Table 8.1. It leaves paramagnetic sensors out of the table because they are often used in analysers built into respiratory equipment; see paramagnetic oxygen analysers.

Galvanic cell (electrochemical)Ultrasonic
PrincipleA galvanic cell is essentially an oxygen-powered battery whose voltage changes with the concentration of oxygenSound travels at different speeds through a gas mixture, which two ultrasound transducers sense to determine the percentage of oxygen
Parameters measuredOxygen concentrationOxygen concentration, and flow rate for some
Detection range (Table 8.1)0 to 99.9%21 to 95.6%
Works forConcentrator oxygen and the low-pressure side of a cylinder supply; also cryogenically generated cylinder oxygenPSA-generated oxygen below 96%, from concentrators or PSA generators; not cryogenically generated oxygen in a cylinder, where the concentration is too high
CalibrationNeeded, usually with room air (21% oxygen) and a source of known concentration, at the pressure of the gas to be measuredNot needed
SensorNeeds replacing; lifetime less than 1 to 2 yearsNo need to replace; lifetime at least 5 years
Other drawbacks listedInfluenced by temperature and pressureCan be damaged by humidity: humidifiers should be removed before testing
Initial costCheapest, in generalHigher, in general
WHO-UNICEF commentRecommended if the sensors are available and in proper supplyRecommended for testing PSA-generated oxygen

Cost over the life of the analyser

WHO-UNICEF adds, in its Box 8.1, that a lower initial device cost does not necessarily mean a lower lifetime cost, because electrochemical analysers need periodic sensor replacements. See how long an oxygen analyser sensor lasts.

Specifications

WHO (2023) says oxygen analysers come as hand-held devices with a digital display and external oxygen sensor, or as sensors installed inside a source of oxygen such as a bedside concentrator or an oxygen generator plant. WHO's 2024 specification for oxygen generator plants lists a hand-held (stand-alone) oxygen analyser for quality control of product among the other system requirements to consider in procurement.

Both specifications in the WHO-UNICEF document ask for an oxygen accuracy within plus or minus 3%. For how handheld analysers fit alongside the analysers of a PSA plant, see portable or fixed oxygen purity analysers.

More questions

Can an ultrasonic analyser test cylinder oxygen from a cryogenic plant?

No. WHO-UNICEF (2019) says ultrasonic technology cannot be used to test cryogenically generated oxygen in a cylinder because the percentage concentration of oxygen is too high.

Which handheld analyser needs calibration?

The galvanic cell analyser. WHO-UNICEF (2019) lists no need for calibration as a merit of the ultrasonic analyser.

Sources

Ultra Controlo figures come from its technical datasheets. Third-party facts were read at the source on the date shown.

Reviewed: · Ultra Controlo engineering · Markdown version

Related